In the time it took me to Google they called me back 3 more times. In total they called me over 30 times yesterday. The only reason I didn't fall for the scam is because a business wouldn't call back to back like that.
I used the customer service chat available through the Venmo app and they informed me it was indeed a scam and that scammers are able to disguise their phone numbers and email addresses to look like ones associated with Venmo.
I'm sure if you do press 1 as they request they would ask you to confirm your account details or something to collect enough info to drain your bank account. Just wanted to spread the word, I think I'm usually on top of these scammers but seeing the actual Venmo # calling really confused me and I almost fell for the trap. Stay safe out there and protect that bread!